Login Register

VIDEO: Six-month ban for Porsche driver who overtook learner bikers at 113mph near Lincolnshire beauty spot

By PWhitelam_LE  |  Posted: January 09, 2013

David Judd overtook reaching over 110mph.

Comments (0)

A Porsche driver who overtook a group of learner motorcyclists at 113mph has been banned from the roads for six months.

David Robert Judd, 30, was found guilty of careless driving and admitted speeding on the A631 at Willingham Woods, near Market Rasen, on May 13.

Lincoln Magistrates' Court heard that seconds after passing the bikes he decelerated to 23mph after spotting a speed camera van.

Judd was fined £600, with £200 costs and a £15 surcharge.

The court heard he referred to himself in police interview as an idiot when his overtaking manoeuvre was put to him.

Judd insisted he was not showing off to anyone.

Magistrates heard his car had previously been under-performing, and performed faster than it used to after an engine fault was fixed.

Judd conceded that as he overtook, the car was travelling "faster than he realised".

The Doncaster man had denied a charge of dangerous driving.

Magistrates were not satisfied his driving fell far below the expected standard to be considered dangerous.

Judd's lawyer Steve Smith argued his client  was past the picnic area when he overtook, there was a "nice" overtaking gap between the car and the bikes, and a safe distance between the vehicles when he braked.

Mr Smith added that at no point did Judd lose control of his car, attributing a "slight veer" after braking to a technical fault with the braking system.

Read more from Lincolnshire Echo

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • InsideStory  |  January 13 2013, 11:46AM

    Drivers who purchase a high performance,powered vehicle should by law need an upgrade to their licence with training and test at the end to prove they are mentally,physically.and capable of handling such a vehicle the same as new drivers having to upgrade to 7.5 ton trucks,to tow trailer,caravans and the same as motorcyclists who need to pass tests to upgrade to higher powered bikes.Many people try to run before they can walk and by making these drivers take an upgrade to their licence the roads might be a safer place. Bus and lorry drivers cant swap jobs unless they have the licence for the appropriate vehicle although the chassis and weight limits are almost identical so car drivers should not be able to either.

    |   1
  • exechef  |  January 12 2013, 8:25AM

    How ironic! It's usually motorbikes overtaking cars at these kinds of speeds on this stretch of road! My guess is that the car driver saw the motorbikes and decided that he was going to have a little play, pitching his toy up against high powered motorcycles. A perfect stereo-type,,take a 30 something male, his penis extension, fully kitted with naff' personalised number plate, a female riding shot-gun to impress, this was some-what inevitable. Now whilst I do not agree that the 'speed kills' tag line of the Lincolnshire Road Safety Partnership, is correct, I feel that the facts of this incident are transparant and should have resulted in a more severe sentence. Perhaps we ought to go down a similar route to the new motorcycle testing procedure, governing the engine output size dependant on age and exerience? I am sure that if we were operating system where-by we continuously add onto our driving license benefits, i.e engine size/performance, this would lead to us having a more precious view of our document. Perhaps this would also go some way towards reducing insurance premiums? Just some thoughts.....

  • Roadscource  |  January 10 2013, 10:52AM

    "Where do you draw the line between "Safe" speeding, and reckless driving" We dont, which is what annoys most motorists. I would say that in the situation shown on film it was a poor driving decision but then coming from that direction he had probably had to follow them for 20 miles. A pair of glasses wouldnt go amiss either if he couldnt see the van at that distance.

    |   -8
  • nottsred  |  January 10 2013, 10:43AM

    "Where do you draw the line between "Safe" speeding, and reckless driving" Driving at that speed where there are pedestrians walking (especially children who could suddenly run out) might be a start. Or maybe overtaking a learner motorcyclist who could make an unexpected move due to inexperience. Or even putting the motorcyclists in danger by braking suddenly in front of them for no reason other than to attempt to avoid being caught driving too fast.

    |   3
  • peeunit  |  January 10 2013, 9:06AM

    All I'm saying is, people will always break the speed limit, whether its by 10 mph (which you think is acceptable for some reason) or 53mph (which you don't think is acceptable) We're not going to change that, all we can do, is put speed cameras and guns up around the country, and make money from those people. Which is whats happened here. Where do you draw the line between "Safe" speeding, and reckless driving, especially when the person in question is driving a high performance car, capable of breaking from 112mph to 23 so quickly. Thats it I'm leaving it there.

    |   -15
  • M_C_Donald  |  January 09 2013, 10:17PM

    Should have crushed his car too. Peeunit, I have broken the speed limit: 80 on the motorway, 35 in a 30 zone, but I have never broken the speed limit by 53 mph. People this reckless should never be allowed back on the road. I think he got off lightly.

    |   1
  • Localperson55  |  January 09 2013, 9:32PM

    Peeunit - it's not being insular. This type of driving kills people. He was lucky and other people on that road in Market Rasen were also lucky. I would also like to have made some 'insular comments about another story - "Louth man caused six fractures to seven-week-old daughter while changing her" but it is not open to comment.

    |   6
  • Roadscource  |  January 09 2013, 5:05PM

    Thanks Cookieman so Lincoln_Biker was saying that although now residing in Doncaster, the man was originally from Sheffield. We still dont know what "showing off" is though so im going to assume it means "dangerous driving".

  • peeunit  |  January 09 2013, 4:54PM

    ooh, lets all comment on how angry we are, and single handedly fix the "Speeding problem" on the roads, by saying this guy was an idiot, and he should have a re-test, and he's a moron and feel so good about ourselves, and "Like" similar comments to ours. Seriously, are your lives that insular that this is whats winding you up the most at the moment?? Get over it.

    |   -18
  • Cookieman  |  January 09 2013, 4:28PM

    @ Lincoln_Biker @Roadscource "deedah from Doncaster" A Deedah is someone who comes from Sheffield not Doncaster... :) Anyone who drives over 100mph on a public road should face an automatic re-test.

    |   3